Optimal Cabinet Size
Philip Copeman
25 June 2024
COPEMAN:
Management theory teaches us that managers should have enough time to do their own job and then have no more than four team members reporting directly to them. President (1) Reporting to President, Deputy President plus three,(5) Reporting to DP four (13)
Chatgpt: What is the ideal size for a governments' executive cabinet? Please give a one page motivation
CHATGPT:
Ideal Size for a Government's Executive Cabinet: A Motivated Analysis
Management theory provides crucial insights into optimal organizational structures, emphasizing the need for leaders to balance their own responsibilities with effective supervision of their teams. According to these principles, a manager should directly oversee no more than four team members to ensure efficient and effective management. Applying this logic to the structure of a government’s executive cabinet yields a model that balances leadership efficiency, accountability, and representation.
Proposed Structure Based on Management Theory
1. President (1): The President is the head of the executive branch, responsible for overall governance and strategic direction.
2. Reporting to the President: Deputy President plus Three Senior Ministers:
- The Deputy President and three senior ministers report directly to the President, ensuring that the President has a manageable number of direct reports for focused oversight and strategic decision-making.
3. Reporting to the Deputy President: Four Senior Ministers where one of the Senior Ministers manages Four Junior Ministers:
- The Deputy President oversees four senior ministers, each responsible for major governmental sectors.
- Additionally, each of these four senior ministers is supported by one junior minister, allowing for more specialized focus and division of labor.
This structure results in a total of 13 members in the executive cabinet, ensuring a streamlined and effective governance model.
Advantages of a 13-Member Executive Cabinet
1. Efficiency in Decision-Making:
- With 13 members, the cabinet can make decisions swiftly, avoiding the delays and complexities associated with larger groups.
- Smaller groups tend to communicate more effectively, which is crucial for responsive and agile governance.
2. Enhanced Accountability:
- A smaller cabinet allows for clear delineation of responsibilities, making it easier to monitor performance and hold individuals accountable for their actions.
- With defined roles and fewer members, accountability is more straightforward, promoting transparency and trust in government operations.
3. Cohesion and Coordination:
- A cabinet of 13 members fosters closer working relationships, enhancing coordination and teamwork.
- This structure ensures that policies are implemented cohesively across different sectors, promoting a unified government strategy.
4. Focused Oversight:
- The President and Deputy President can provide more focused oversight to their direct reports, ensuring that strategic goals are being pursued effectively.
- This oversight helps maintain alignment with national priorities and prevents fragmentation of government efforts.
5. Representation and Expertise:
- While maintaining a compact size, a 13-member cabinet can still include diverse expertise and representation from different regions and sectors.
- This inclusivity is crucial for democratic legitimacy and ensuring that various interests and perspectives are considered in policy-making.
6. Cost-Effectiveness:
- A smaller cabinet is more cost-effective, reducing the financial burden on the government.
- The savings from a leaner cabinet can be redirected to essential public services and development projects, maximizing the use of public funds.
Case Studies and Best Practices
Examining successful governance models globally reveals that countries with smaller cabinets, such as Sweden and New Zealand, often exhibit higher efficiency and better governance outcomes. These examples underscore the benefits of a streamlined executive branch that prioritizes efficiency, accountability, and cohesive policy-making.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the ideal size for a government's executive cabinet, guided by management theory, is 13 members. This size strikes the right balance between efficient decision-making, enhanced accountability, cohesive policy implementation, and cost-effectiveness. By maintaining a manageable number of direct reports at each level of the hierarchy, the government can ensure effective oversight and strategic alignment, ultimately leading to better governance and improved outcomes for the nation.
The Prisoners Dilemma
2 June 2024
Theory of Games and Economic Behavior, published in 1944 by Princeton University Press, is a book by mathematician John von Neumann and economist Oskar Morgenstern which is considered the ground-breaking text that created the interdisciplinary research field of game theory.
An early product of game theory is the prisoners dilemma. Take the following example:
Three of us have broken into a house and stashed the loot. We get caught by the cops and put into separate cells. Our lawyers tell us, they have not found the loot. We are fine if none of us talk. We each get one year for damage to property. That is three years time served in total. Good cop comes in and tells us each of us if we confess he will get one of us off on a plea bargain. The other two will do five years for theft. Ten years in total served.
Good cop goes to the weakest prisoner and bad cop goes to the second offenders.
Good cop tells us we have five minutes to make up our minds because bad cop is making the same offer to the others.
Now the obvious move is none of us talk and we walk after one year.
Or is it?
In empirical studies the majority of prisoners talk! It gets even worse if the three prisoners each blame each other. Good cop wins.
Now apply it in real life. ANC is good cop, DA, EFF and MK are the prisoners. Instead of taking one year to get over our differences, and sweep the ANC out of power, DA bursts into tears and confesses. EFF and MK will spend five years in red and orange overalls.
In the prisoners dilemma it is usually best to be the first to confess. Until you find that good cop breaks his word...
Now take a step back, stop looking at the blonde, and consider that the ONLY coalition that can actually take South Africa forward, The golden coalition of DA, EFF, MK (47%) and 4% of a minority party. (51%).
Suggested Reading
Copeman, Philip, Mark Beckenstrater, The Prosperity Plan, 2024, www.turbocash.net/a/pages/prosperityplan
McCarty,Nolan, Adam MeirowitPolitical Game Theory, Princeton, 2024, https://www.princeton.edu/~nmccarty/Political_Game_Theory%20.pdf
Copeman, Philip, Forecasting Inflation with Input Output Analysis MBA Thesis University of the Witwatersrand, 1982 Forecasting Inflation with Input Output Analysis
Piketty, Thomas. Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Translated by Arthur Goldhammer, Belknap Press, 2017. Capital in the Twenty-First Century - Wikipedia
Boushey, Heather, J. Bradford DeLong and Marshall Steinbaum, After Piketty: The Agenda for Economics and Inequality, Harvard University Press 2017. Including Solow,Robert, Piketti was Right and Krugman, Paul, We live in a new Gilded Age. After Piketty - Wikipedia
Pasinetti, Luigi L, Growth and Income Distribution, Essays in Economic Theory, Cambridge University Press, 1974 Growth and Income Distribution, Essays in Economic Theory"
Pasinetti, Luigi L, Structural Change and Economic Growth , A theoretical Essay on the dynamics of Wealth of Nations, Cambridge University Press, 1981 Structural change and economic growth: A theoretical essay on the dynamics of the wealth of nations
Furman, Ryan, Okun’s Law: Economic Growth and Unemployment, Investopedia , 2023, Okun's Law
Ball, Laurence, João Tovar Jalles, and Prakash Loungani, Do Forecasters Believe in Okun’s Law? An Assessment of Unemployment and Output Forecasts, International Monetary Fund, 2014. IMF
Rasure, Erika, The Investopedia Team, Home Market Effect: What It Means, How It Works, Implications, 2021. Investopedia
Reinert, Erik, How Rich Countries Got Rich ... and Why Poor Countries Stay Poor, PublicAffairs, 2019. How Rich Countries Got Rich and Why Poor Countries Stay Poor by Erik S. Reinert | Goodreads
Ghosh ,Jayati, Review of How Rich Countries Got Rich and Why Poor Countries Stay Poor, International Development Economics Associates, 2007. IDEA
Reinert, Erik, Austrian Economics and The Other Canon. Published in Backhaus, Jürgen (editor), Evolutionary Economic Thought. European Contributions and Concepts, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar, 2003, pp.160-207.
Reinert-1.pdf (hetecon.net)
Phillips, Joseph D The Zen Art of Firewall Economics, 2019 Firewall Economics
Ricardo, David, Anonymous, The Theory of Comparative Advantage- Overview, LibreTexts 2023. 2.2: The Theory of Comparative Advantage- Overview - Social Sci LibreTexts
Sobukwe, Mangaliso Robert, Speeches of Managliso Robert Sobukwe, Inagural Address, Pan Africanist Congress. 1959 PAC
Ricker, Thomas, The Verge, 92 million US workers now have the opportunity to work remotely: survey , 2022. 92 million US workers now have the opportunity to work remotely: survey - The Verge
South Africa’s Special Economic Zones. 2022 SEZ-brochure_2021.pdf (thedtic.gov.za)
Mona,Positive and Negative Impacts of Tourism in Paris. The French Hotel Guide , 2022,
The French Hotel Guide"
Copeman, Philip, Southern Sunset, 2013, Southern Sunset (turbocash.net)
Chatterjee, Aroop et al, South Africa: How extreme inequality persists, 2022, Culturico, South Africa: How extreme inequality persists - Culturico
IMF, Six Charts Explain South Africa's Inequality, 2022, Six Charts Explain South Africa's Inequality (imf.org)
Wikipedia, Contributors agreement, Wikipedia 2024 Contributor License Agreement - Wikipedia
European Commission, Creative Commons Int 4.0 Licence. 2024. Contributor License Agreement - Wikipedia ,
Wikidiff, Libertareanism vs Socialism - What's the difference? , 2024, Libertarianism vs Socialism - What's the difference? | WikiDiff
World Economic Forum, World’s Best Countries for Remote Working, 2023
Global Remote Work Index 2023 ranks remote-working countries | World Economic Forum (weforum.org)
Upwork, The Best 30 remote work Jobs in 2024, | Upwork
(#damanifesto) Democratic Alliance, 2024 Election Manifesto, 2024, DA-Election-Manifesto-2024.pdf
Sobukwe, Magaliso Robert,Speeches of Sobukwe Inaugural Address, 1959 Speeches
Keynes, John Maynard, The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money, 1935 (keynes-general-theory.com)
Economics HelpThe Harrod Doma-Model and its limitations Harrod-Domar Model of Growth and its Limitations - Economics Help
Investopedia, Erica Razure, 2021, Home Market Effect: What It Means, How It Works, Implications, (investopedia.com) 2024 (investopedia.com)
Stats SA, Stats SA releases new provincial GDP figures, 2023 | Statistics South Africa
Shakespeare, William, Coriolanis, 1605 Coriolanus - Entire Play | Folger Shakespeare Library
Will Kenton et al, What is Merchantalism? Investopedia, 2024 (investopedia.com)
Upwork, Gig Economy Statistics and Key Takeaways for 2024 | Upwork
Amon, Romj et al, 35 Stunning Freelance Statistics You Need To Know in 2024 (techjury.net)
How Peru became the king of blueberries | International | EL PAÍS English (elpais.com)
South Africa's unemployment rises (thesouthafrican.com)
Our World in Data Comparing Gini over time and over country Income inequality: Gini coefficient, 1963 to 2023 (ourworldindata.org)
Hasel, Joe, Measuring inequality: what is the Gini coefficient?- Our World in Data
World Bank, Gini Coefficient vs Per capita GDP, 2023 Income inequality: Gini coefficient, 1963 to 2023 (ourworldindata.org)
Przybylinski, et al, Forecasting Inflation with Input Output Analysis, University of Łódź, 2017 Przybylinski (iioa.org)
Cobb-Douglas Production Function and Its Properties (economicsdiscussion.net)
Solow's Model of Growth (With Diagram) (economicsdiscussion.net) (economicsdiscussion.net)
Harrod–Domar model - Wikipedia Harrod–Domar model - Wikipedia
Etounga-Manguelle, Daniel, Does Africa need a cultural adjustment? 2000 Does Africa need a cultural adjustment?
StatsSA, Provincial Gross Domestic Product: Experimental Estimates, 2022
Publication | Statistics South Africa (statssa.gov.za)
HMRC Tax on foreign income2024 Gov.uk
top-10-powerful-quotes-of-robert-sobukwe.html
Top 10 Powerful Quotes of Robert Sobukwe - Motivation Africa
Data Sources
FRED
IMF
World Bank
SARB Quarterly Bulliten, South Africa Reserve Bank, 2024
StatsSA, South Africa, 2024
SA Treasury, South Africa, 2024
